We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
A small team may not need a broad payroll-and-HR system if all you want is to pay people and handle payroll taxes. ADP covers payroll and HR, but its pricing can be unclear, and Reddit users describe labor-heavy onboarding and uneven support. Our shortlist puts straightforward payroll first, then options for teams already using QuickBooks or looking to combine payroll with HR. Listed starting prices are not a total for a specific headcount, so ask for an all-in quote.
01Why people leave ADP Payroll
Onboarding can take real effort
One r/humanresources thread describes lengthy calls and spreadsheet-heavy setup; another commenter says implementation took a lot of work.
Support reports are mixed
Some Reddit commenters describe unhelpful service, while another says ADP does what they need. Treat those accounts as individual experiences.
Fit and pricing may be unclear
A commenter says ADP had compatibility trouble with their POS. ADP’s listed starting price is $39, but the final cost depends on your quote.
02The alternatives, ranked by fit
- Straightforward payroll
SurePayrollSurePayrollSurePayroll is a fit to consider if your small team mainly needs payroll and automatic tax filing, rather than a wider HR suite. Its listed starting price is $20; a total for a specific number of employees and any free plan should be confirmed with the vendor. Ask what onboarding includes and whether setup help costs extra.
Trade-off: Confirm the monthly total and included support before signing.
7.0/10from
$20/mo - QuickBooks teams
QuickBooks Online PayrollQuickBooks Online PayrollIf your business already uses QuickBooks, its payroll option may keep payroll and time tracking together. The listed starting price is $25, but a few-seat total is not shown. The base fee can make a small roster cost more, so ask for a quote at your headcount and check what payroll tax filing includes.
Trade-off: The base fee can weigh more heavily on small rosters.
6.2/10from
$25/mo - Payroll plus HR
GustoGustoGusto is worth comparing if you want payroll and HR together, or pay both employees and contractors. The listed starting price is $49, and the cost includes a base fee plus seats, so get a quote for your team size. Ask about available onboarding help and whether a free plan fits your needs.
Trade-off: Budget for the base fee and employee seats.
6.8/10from
$49/mo - Benefits and HR
JustworksJustworksJustworks may suit a small team that wants payroll, HR and benefits administration in one place. Its listed starting price is $8, but that is not an all-in price for a particular team; ask how benefits affect the quote and renewals. Confirm the setup process and what expert support is included.
Trade-off: Check the full cost, including benefits renewals.
6.5/10from
$8/mo - Payroll and HR
PaychexPaychexPaychex is an option if you want payroll and HR together, payroll tax filing, or are considering PEO services. The vendor’s price is not listed, so request an all-in quote for your headcount and ask which services are included. Confirm the onboarding steps, setup costs and whether any free option is available.
Trade-off: You need a quote before comparing costs.
5.0/10from
Custom - Employee self-service
PaycomPaycomPaycom combines payroll and HR, with employee self-service and automated time-off decisions among its listed strengths. It does not publish a starting price here, so ask for a quote for your team and check for added fees. Before choosing it over ADP, ask what implementation requires and how much help comes with the plan.
Trade-off: Custom pricing makes a small-team budget harder to estimate.
5.3/10from
Custom
03Side by side
| Tool | Score | From | Free plan | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5.6 | $39/mo | No | Small teams needing payroll and HR | |
| 7.0 | $20/mo | No | Small businesses with straightforward payroll | |
| 6.2 | $25/mo | No | Small teams already using QuickBooks | |
| 6.8 | $49/mo | No | Small teams running one-state payroll | |
| 6.5 | $8/mo | No | Small teams consolidating payroll and HR | |
| 5.0 | Custom | No | Teams wanting payroll and HR together | |
| 5.3 | Custom | No | Teams wanting payroll and HR together |
Questions people ask
Is ADP similar to QuickBooks?
Both offer payroll. ADP also covers HR, while QuickBooks Online Payroll is aimed at businesses already using QuickBooks and lists payroll tax filing and time tracking. Compare the features you need and ask each vendor for the total cost at your headcount; a starting price alone won’t show your bill.
What is the best payroll software for small businesses?
It depends on what your team needs. SurePayroll is worth considering for straightforward payroll and automatic tax filing; QuickBooks Online Payroll fits teams already using QuickBooks; Gusto and Justworks combine payroll with HR. Compare the all-in price, onboarding and included support before deciding.
Does ADP do payroll?
Yes. ADP covers payroll and HR needs. Its listed starting price is $39, but small teams may need a quote to understand the actual cost. Ask what onboarding involves, which support level is included and whether the system fits your existing tools.
