We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
A small team may not need a PEO if its main job is running payroll. Justworks brings payroll, HR and benefits administration together, but its base fee and benefit renewals deserve a close look. One Reddit thread describes a 36% renewal increase after a 20%-30% increase the previous year. The alternatives below range from payroll-focused tools to broader HR and payroll platforms. Compare the total quote for your headcount, and ask what setup will involve before you commit.
01Why people leave Justworks
Renewal increases
One Reddit thread describes a 36% increase after a previous 20%-30% increase. Commenters suggest comparing open-market and other benefit quotes.
A bundled PEO may be too much
If your main need is payroll, a payroll-focused option may be a better fit than consolidating payroll, HR and benefits.
Costs need a closer look
Justworks' base fee and benefit renewals deserve scrutiny. Compare written quotes for your headcount before choosing.
02The alternatives, ranked by fit
- Small-team payroll
GustoGustoGusto is worth comparing if you run payroll in one state and want HR tools alongside it. Its listed starting price is $49, but the base fee and seat costs can add up for a small roster. It also covers teams paying employees and contractors. Ask for the total at your headcount and what setup requires.
Trade-off: Budget for the base fee and seats; users have reported uneven support.
6.8/10from
$49/mo - QuickBooks users
QuickBooks Online PayrollQuickBooks Online PayrollFor a team already using QuickBooks, Online Payroll starts at $25 and combines payroll tax filing with time tracking. That may suit a small roster better than paying for a broader PEO package. The base fee can still make each seat costly, so ask for a quote at your headcount and confirm setup requirements.
Trade-off: The base fee weighs more heavily when you have few employees.
6.2/10from
$25/mo - Straightforward payroll
SurePayrollSurePayrollSurePayroll starts at $20 and is aimed at small businesses with straightforward payroll and automatic tax filing. It is a practical option to price if you want payroll rather than a broader PEO arrangement. Confirm your monthly price for your team size, and ask the vendor what setup involves before switching.
Trade-off: Confirm your actual monthly price before deciding.
7.0/10from
$20/mo - Payroll and HR
PaychexPaychexPaychex covers payroll and HR, offers payroll tax filing, and has PEO services to consider. It could suit a small team comparing bundled support with Justworks, but the vendor does not publish a starting price. Request a quote for your headcount and ask which services are included and how setup works.
Trade-off: You need a quote to judge whether it fits your budget.
5.0/10from
Custom - Broader workforce tools
PaylocityPaylocityPaylocity combines HR and payroll and also offers finance and IT tools and workforce reporting. It may be worth a quote if your team wants more than basic payroll. There is no free plan or published starting price, so ask for the cost at your headcount and what implementation will involve.
Trade-off: No free plan or published price makes budgeting harder.
5.2/10from
Custom - Employee self-service
PaycomPaycomPaycom brings payroll and HR together, with employee self-service and automated time-off decisions among its listed strengths. A small team can compare it with Justworks if those functions matter more than a PEO bundle. Paycom does not publish a starting price, so request a quote and ask about setup before weighing it.
Trade-off: You need a quote to learn the cost.
5.3/10from
Custom
03Side by side
| Tool | Score | From | Free plan | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6.5 | $8/mo | No | Small teams consolidating payroll and HR | |
| 6.8 | $49/mo | No | Small teams running one-state payroll | |
| 6.2 | $25/mo | No | Small teams already using QuickBooks | |
| 7.0 | $20/mo | No | Small businesses with straightforward payroll | |
| 5.0 | Custom | No | Teams wanting payroll and HR together | |
| 5.2 | Custom | No | Small employers consolidating HR and payroll | |
| 5.3 | Custom | No | Teams wanting payroll and HR together |
Questions people ask
How much does Justworks PEO cost?
We don't have a reliable figure to quote. Ask Justworks for a written price for your headcount, with the base fee and benefits costs broken out where applicable. Also ask how renewals are handled, then compare the total with quotes from alternatives.
Is Justworks a PEO or HRIS?
Justworks is a PEO that brings payroll, HR and benefits administration together. If you only need payroll, compare payroll-focused alternatives such as SurePayroll or QuickBooks Online Payroll. If benefits administration matters, compare the services and total costs in each vendor's quote.
What are the top payroll companies for small teams?
There is no single best fit for every small team. Gusto, QuickBooks Online Payroll, SurePayroll, Paychex and Paylocity are options to compare here. Check the listed starting price where available, request a quote when pricing is not published, and weigh the tools your team will actually use.
